The past two days we have seen two developments on the Roy Halladay to Philadelphia front. On Saturday it was reported that the Phillies had rejected an offer from the Blue Jays. That deal would have sent J.A. Happ, Kyle Drabek and number one Phillies prospect Dominic Brown to Toronto is exchange for the best pitcher in the history of ever. Logically, the Phillies declined this offer, and countered with one of their own.
In the Philadelphia version of the trade, the Phillies were to send Happ, Michael Taylor, Carlos Carrasco and Jason Donald all to Toronto. The Blue Jays declined the offer, which is about as good of an offer as I can see them getting.
Taylor, who entered the year as the sixth ranked prospect in the Phillies’ system, was promoted earlier this month to AAA Lehigh Valley, is very highly regarded by the Phillies right now, and could be called up in September when the rosters expand. After raking to a tune of a .333 batting average and 0.977 OPS in AA, Taylor has been having his issues in AAA. That being said, he just came off a six game hitting streak that has his average sitting at .263 for the Iron Pigs, with two homers in 38 at-bats. Hopefully the six game streak was a sign of things to come, and Taylor gets things going.
Carrasco, the Phillies second best prospect headed into the year, has had a rough season so far in AAA, as he is currently sporting a 5.18 ERA and a 1.32 WHIP. He is going to have to do much better than this if he wants to be the future #2 starter for the Phillies, but his 112:33 K:BB ratio shows that he still knows how to get strikeouts while keeping command of his pitches. That may not carry over to the Bigs, and it will be interesting to see if Carrasco gets a call in September himself. As things stand now, Carlos is not ready for the next level, but a 2010 arrival date should be expected.
Jason Donald started the season as the fourth ranked prospect for the Phils. Like Taylor, Donald struggled when he got to AAA. Unlike Taylor, however, Donald is no longer in AAA, but rather back at the Gulf Coast League, which is a rookie league. He is doing better since being demoted, but still not gaining any traction with his bat. Donald was heralded as the heir apparent to Jimmy Rollins, but his career is trending in the wrong direction for a 24 year old at this point.
All in all, a very solid offer for Halladay, and one I am surprised the Blue Jays turned down, but I can see the logic. If the Phillies are going to get a current Major League ace like Roy Halladay, they are going to have to part ways with their best pitching prospect. While that may have been Carrasco back in March, it is now clearly Kyle Drabek, who the Phillies have allegedly labeled as untouchable. Personally, I do not see how the Phillies can expect Toronto to give up Halladay and not get the best pitching prospect from the team they send him to. You have to give up something to get something, especially when that something is the arguable front runner for the AL Cy Young award.
Recent Comments