Carlos Carrasco entered this season as the “co” number one prospect in the Phillies’ farm system with Dominic Brown being the other “co” number one guy. Carrasco has seen his stock go down this season, as he has toiled away to a 5.18 this season, his first full season in AAA. While his strikeouts are still there, he does have 112 of them in 114.2 innings, so are the hits and walks, to the tune of a 1.36 WHIP. Carrasco, who is only 22 years old at this point, could still turn out to be a top line pitcher, but right now his cap is looking like a three in the rotation.
Jason Donald has recently been described as a future utility man in the Majors. For your fourth ranked prospect, you hope for a better fate than that, and the Phillies used to hope he would supplant Jimmy Rollins at short. Well, before this season even started those expectations had shifted towards the utility role, and after dude has raked to a .235 batting average this season you can guess where those expectations are at this point. Maybe Donald, who is 24 years old, can turn it around in the batters box, but in order to do so he will have to stop striking out so much (he has 58 Ks in 234 at-bats, which projects out to over 150 over a full season in the Bigs).
Jason Knapp is 6′5″ of raw talent. Dude can hit triple digits on the radar gun, has a decent changeup, a power slider and a breaking ball. Problem is Knapp can not seem to develop a consistent delivery, which causes him to change planes and lose his command. As things stand, Knapp is projected to be an overpowering set-up man in the Majors, and possibly a closer. He is young as well, though, at only 18 years of age, so there is time to refine his approach and develop him into a starter if he is durable enough.
Lou Marson was the catcher of the future for the Phillies. Through 63 games, the third ranked ranked prospect is hitting for a .294 average and a .751 OPS in AAA. During a brief stint in the Majors, he hit .235 with a .644 OPS. Like Donald, Marson has been missing too many pitches, as he does strikeout a bit too much. Will Marson be a top tier catcher in the Majors at some point? No one knows, but the 23 year old has talent to go with his professional approach.
Those are the prospects being sent to Cleveland. A probable utility man, a power bully, a future three in the rotation, and a catcher. Well, they are giving up something else as well, as someone is going to lose a starting rotation spot.
So in the end, what the Phillies gave up for Lee is hard to quantify. This entry will be added to the “featured posts” section for easy reference next year when we revisit this deal.












Recent Comments